erplogobit.JPG (7484 bytes)

March 2000, Technology Corner
by Rob Hirschfeld

Application Service Providers: Tactical Technology

Jump to: Links to ASP related information

It is time to admit defeat in the war you have been waging to control technology costs.  The pace of innovation and the demands of the global market place have left tread marks on your budgets and your ERP consultants have just stormed your data center (again).  Before you surrender to yet another round of computer-related capital investments, take some time to learn about a new approach to efficiently deliver technology to businesses that may out-flank your attacking technology spending. 

This new approach can reduce technology expenditures while making them more manageable and predictable, make multi-location operations trivial and seamless, and enable you to make a profit while keeping up with the pace of change.  These benefits are available today from a growing fleet of vendors known as Application Service Providers (ASP).  

How does an ASP work?

The ASP maintains all the servers, software, and personnel to run your applications at their data center.  You access your software using direct connections, private networks, or the Internet.  The concept has been in use since the days of Mainframe time-sharing, but recent Internet and Windows Terminal technologies provide efficient access to modern sophisticated user interfaces over connections as slow as dial-up modem. 

Many companies lose their ability to focus on customer value in their struggle to balance technology dollars against return on investment.  The costs and risks are so high that only very large companies have the resources to get full value from technology.  Navigating the maze of software and hardware options requires expert guidance: even with professional help, many companies give up rather than buy the systems that would really support their business. 

A Competitive Advantage

The winners in today’s markets use technology as a tool to drive their business not as an end in itself.  When you use an ASP, your technology infrastructure is managed externally so you can focus internal resources on building business value from the technology.  Your ASP takes over the responsibility for staffing a data center, buying computer hardware and software, maintaining and deploying upgrades, backing up and securing the data, and even handling telecommunications with remote locations.  Technology outsourcing frees you to run your business. 

The benefits of outsourcing are larger than simply outsourcing your technology management.  An ASP leverages economies of scale unavailable to individual businesses.  This translates into services generally available to only large companies like sophisticated ERP, CRM, or Supply Chain software, Internet and eCommerce features, effective multi-site management, and telecommuting.  

For Example

Let’s look at a typical ERP upgrade scenario.  A mid-range manufacturer ($25 million gross) wants to upgrade their DOS based ERP package.  Even though they are small with just 1 tech support person, they still have 2 locations, 25 users, and their supply chain requires them to implement XML based EDI.  After an extensive search, they find a good software match.  Unfortunately, the expected implementation price tag nears $2 million and requires them to deploy an Oracle database.  The manufacturer must both invest the capital for the new system and take all the risk for its success. 

In the ASP model, the capital investment and risk is much lower.  There is no computer hardware to buy since the ASP owns the servers and a team of DBAs to maintain the Oracle database.   Since the ERP software is already part of the ASP’s suite of applications, the manufacturer only pays for the licenses they need (for approximately 30% of retail per year).  Even more important, the ASP has already deployed the manufacturer’s critical EDI features and offers custom integrations between the ERP software and Microsoft Office.  Finally, the ASP eliminates their multi-site issues: since all operations are remote there is no tangible difference to users at either site or even working from home. 

What’s the catch?

The flip side to all these amazing benefits is an increased reliance on wide area networks and the Internet.  In order for your business to use an ASP, you will need as much reliable data capacity (bandwidth) as you can afford.  If your bandwidth is not reliable or too limited, your business cannot adequately access its software.  

Yet, even without using an ASP, bandwidth issues are already a fact of life.  Companies already are supporting complex telecommunications infrastructure to provide telephones, call centers, Internet access, integrated web sites, data links for multiple sites, and even dial-up for telecommuters.  The list of critical bandwidth needs will only increase as data networks and voice systems converge.  In fact, most businesses I visit find that their telecommunications spending is growing even faster than their technology outlay.  When an ASP takes over your data center, they actually simplify these communication issues. 

Security is another critical issue for ASP users to consider because subscribers must entrust their critical data and operations to a third party.  The reality is that ASPs actually offer improved security because most businesses have such poor security (see the Nov/Dec 1999 Technology Corner “What you don’t want to know about computer security”).  ASPs enhance security by enforcing uniform standards, limiting internal users with administrator access, having the data removed physically from your location, and providing regular backups.  In addition, an ASP uses economies of scale to employ specialists and deploy technologies that individual businesses could not afford.

 Early Adopters

Since the ASP model is still emerging, early adopters are taking a risk: these businesses will have needs that are uniquely suited for outsourced applications such as multiple locations, rapid implementation or growth needs, mixed operating system environments (like Macintosh, Unix, and Windows), complex software with relational databases, or tightly integrated the eCommerce requirements.  Using an ASP does not require giving up all of your technology management.  Early adopters will select to outsource applications with the highest return on investment.  

In addition to partial deployment, early adopters risk exposure is minimized because the ASP model not really new.  Large companies, and progressive small ones, have been successfully deploying internal ASP's for over two years.  The primary differences between these internal hosts and an ASP vendor are the outsourcing elements and scale of the data center. 

Early Vendors

Even in early stages of the ASP market, the vendor's seem to be separating into two tiers.  The first tier vendors are focused on delivering specific applications and tier 1 ERP products such as Oracle and PeopleSoft.  Their target markets are large or fast-growing businesses and companies looking for custom Web applications.  The second tier vendors are targeting small and midsize companies.  Their goal is to supply all necessary applications for their customers: these applications range from email and word processing to second and third tier ERP software.  

The ASP model has been moving from concept to establishment.  The technology community has been raving about ASP’s since last October and the concept is now gaining acceptance in business circles.  Every major technology vendor is seeking to support ASPs: Microsoft is starting a major ASP push with the 2/17 release of Windows2000, IBM is deploying suites of software to support ASPs, and Sun is planning to rent their StarOffice package.  Even hardware vendors like Dell, Micron, Compaq, and HP have are lining up behind the model.  In addition, nearly every telephone company and ISP has announced an ASP partnership or strategy.  With so much activity, the ASP vendor list is changing too quickly for print: visit my website, www.H-Consulting.com, for an up-to-date vendor list. 

Back to the battle!

I have been in the trenches helping businesses win battles when deploying or enhancing technology; yet most companies feel like they are loosing the war.  ASP's can change the rules of engagement: they help their subscribers to not only manage technology, but take advantage of emerging capabilities.  The next time you are sitting in a meeting discussing your three-year eCommerce strategy or your next ERP upgrade; remember, ASP’s are a new arrow in your quiver.

ASP Links

Interested in reading more?  Click here for more articles.

Originally appeared in MidrangeERP, Mar 2000.  Used with permission.